Mustang V6 or EcoBoost: Which Is Best For You?

Mustang V6 or EcoBoost: Which Is Best For You?

Last Updated November 18, 2016
Contents

The V8 Isn’t An Option For You; What Now?

So, at this point you’ve ruled out the GT with the big, torquey 435 horsepower Coyote V8 engine. It could be because of the gas mileage, price point or even just plain practicality – regardless, it’s not the Mustang for you. Don’t fret! There are other options out there – meet the 3.7L V6 and 2.3L I-4 EcoBoost engines.

With both engines in the 300 horsepower range, these non-V8 Mustang engine options are no slouch when it comes to power. To put it in perspective, those kind of horsepower numbers are higher than the V8s from the 1994-2004 and 2005-2010 eras!

Now that you’ve narrowed the V8 out of the equation, it comes down to choosing between the 3.7L V6 “Cyclone” engine or the all-new 2.3L turbo-charged EcoBoost I-4 engine. Each have pros and cons to weigh into your decision, and that’s what this article is all about!

The Numbers

Numbers don’t lie! Just because they’re non-V8 engines doesn’t mean that they are all the same. When it gets down to it, there are actually a considerable amount of differences between the Mustang’s 3.7L and 2.3L EcoBoost engines. Check out some of the cold, hard numbers below.

Basic Highlights, via Ford
Vehicle2015-2016 Mustang V62015-2016 Mustang EcoBoost
Vehicle Base Price (2016 MY) $24,295 $25,795
Engine 3.7L Ti-VCT V-6 Engine 2.3L GTDI I-4 Engine
Horsepower (SAE net @ RPM) 300 @ 6,500 310 @ 5,500 (93-octane fuel)
Torque (lb.-ft. @ RPM) 280 @ 4,000 320 @ 3,000 (93-octane fuel)
Compression Ratio 10.5:1 9.5:1
Bore and Stroke (mm) 95.5 x 86.7 87.5 x 94
Fuel Delivery Sequential Multi-port Electronic Fuel Injection Direct Injection
EPA-Estimated MPG 17 city / 28 hwy / 21 combined (M/T)
19 city / 28 hwy / 22 combined (A/T)
22 city / 31 hwy / 25 combined (M/T)
21 city / 32 hwy / 25 combined (A/T)
Front Brakes 320 (12.6 in.) x 30-mm vented
discs, twin-piston 43-mm
floating aluminum calipers
320 (12.6 in.) x 30-mm vented
discs, twin-piston 43-mm
floating aluminum calipers;

Performance Package:
352 (13.9 in.) x 32-mm vented
discs, four-piston 46-mm fixed
aluminum calipers
Rear Brakes 320 (1 2.6 in.) x 12-mm solid
discs, single-piston 45-mm
floating aluminum calipers,
integral parking brake
320 (1 2.6 in.) x 12-mm solid
discs, single-piston 45-mm
floating aluminum calipers,
integral parking brake
Base Curb Weight 3,526 lbs (M/T) / 3,530 (A/T) 3,532 lbs (M/T) / 3,524 lbs (A/T)
Fuel Capacity (gal.) 16 gallons 15.5 gallons
Performance Numbers, via Car & Driver
Test Vehicle2015-2016 Mustang V6 (A/T)2015-2016 Mustang EcoBoost (M/T, Perf Pack)
0-60 MPH 5.5 sec 5.5 sec
0-100 MPH 13.4 sec 13.3 sec
Quarter Mile (ET @ MPH) 14.1 sec @ 102 mph 13.9 sec @ 102 mph
Top Speed (MPH) 124 mph, governor limited 148 mph, governor limited
Braking, 70-0 MPH (Feet) 164 ft 157 ft
Skidpad (300-ft diameter) 0.86 g 0.98 g

Breaking Down The Facts

2015 Mustang V6 Parts At CJ Pony Parts 2015 Mustang V6

As you can see, the performance numbers between the two are relatively close in comparison. With the 13.9 vs 14.1 second quarter miles between the EcoBoost and V6, respectively, it’s a pretty tight match. But the turbo-charged four cylinder motor inches ahead of the V6 to take the win.

Another small difference between the two would be the gas tank capacities. It’s unconfirmed, but Ford may have done this in an effort to cut down on weight for the EcoBoost ever so slightly. In the long run, it really doesn’t amount to much since the EcoBoost gets slightly better gas mileage than the V6, resulting in near equal miles per tank numbers.

At this point, you’ve probably noticed the differences in both skidpad g-forces and braking from 70-0 MPH. The EcoBoost has a clear advantage over the V6 these categories due to the availability of the Performance Package only on the turbo-four. Thanks to the larger 13.9” four-piston brakes up front and sticky 255mm Pirelli P-Zero summer tires, the EcoBoost is able to come to a halt quicker and hold on to the asphalt with ease around turns. The V6 comes standard with all-season tires which is great for a daily driver, rental or even some spirited driving, but they definitely don’t stand up to the sticky P-Zero summers on the track.

The EcoBoost’s Performance Package

Mustang EcoBoost Parts At CJ Pony Parts 2015 Mustang EcoBoost With Performance Package

The Performance Package isn’t just a set of sticky tires and larger brakes. For an additional $1,995 to Ford, your four-cylinder Mustang will be gifted with a larger rear sway bar (Fastback only), unique chassis tuning, larger 13.9” front brake rotors with four-piston calipers, those sticky 255/40R19 P-Zero tires, a larger radiator, unique EPAS, ABS and stability control tuning and much, much more.

In the grand scheme of things, it really is a deal considering you get all of those things for about $2,000 when the wheels and tires alone would cost you that much in the aftermarket. If you plan on the occasional autocross session, track day or just like a spirited drive through some backroads, the EcoBoost’s Performance Package is definitely a leg up over its V6 counterpart.


The EcoBoost Performance Package includes:

  • Upsized rear sway bar (Fastback only)
  • Unique chassis tuning
  • 13.9" front brake rotors with four-piston calipers
  • Unique 19”x9” Ebony Black-Painted Aluminum Wheels
  • 255/40R19 summer-only tires
  • Unique EPAS, ABS and stability control tuning
  • Engine turn aluminum instrument panel applique
  • Interior gauge pack (oil pressure and boost)
  • 3.55 limited-slip rear axle
  • Larger radiator
  • Heavy-duty front springs (Fastback only)
  • Spoiler delete

How These Engines Make Similar Power In Much Different Ways

Mustang V6 Engine Parts At CJ Pony Parts 2015 Mustang V6 Engine Bay With Roush Intake

Both the 3.7L V6 and 2.3L I-4 make similar power numbers. But, they both do it very differently. This is due to the fact the V6 is naturally aspirated and the I-4 is turbocharged. A turbocharged motor will make power in a different way because the operation of a turbo dictated by exhaust flow. When RPM is low, there’s less exhaust flow, which means less “spool” or pounds of boost. This lack of exhaust flow and boost at low RPM is known as “turbo lag,” but that’s a conversation for another day.

As the RPM rises, the exhaust flow increases and spools the turbo quicker and quicker. However, most factory turbos are relatively small because they’re made to operate at efficiency in the mid-range (2,000-4,000 RPM) of the power band. This means that the turbo spools up pretty quick, but runs out of steam as the RPM rises. That’s why some say the EcoBoost can “fall on its face” in the higher RPM – this is clear on the dyno chart where you see both horsepower and torque fall off after ~5,500 RPM.

Mustang Dyno Graphs At CJ Pony Parts

The operation of a naturally aspirated motor is much simpler in nature. Since there isn’t any forced induction like a turbo, there’s no interruption in air flow throughout the power band such as turbo lag. The result is a nice, smooth torque curve all the way through, unlike the EcoBoost’s torque curve which builds power quickly after 2,000 RPM once it has sufficient boost.

Mustang EcoBoost Engine Parts At CJ Pony Parts 2015 Mustang EcoBoost Engine Bay With COBB Intake

The biggest difference between the 2.3L EcoBoost and the 3.7L V6 engines can be found in the mid-range. The EcoBoost essentially has a shelf beginning at 2,000 RPM and carrying pretty steady until about 5,000 RPM. Whereas the six cylinder motor has a steady, flat torque curve throughout the same range. What does this mean? Well, torque is the seat-of-the-pants feeling you get when you accelerate in your Mustang. Due to the quick wall of low-end torque for the EcoBoost, you’re going to get a quick burst of oomph once the turbo catches up with the exhaust flow. On the other hand, the naturally aspirated V6 will be a steady, smooth acceleration all the way through due to the flat torque curve.

So what does all this mean? The nature of a turbocharged motor is a bit different than what most are used to from a naturally aspirated motor. The majority of time is spent in the mid-range, so for EcoBoost owners that wall of torque at 2,000 RPM can definitely be fun. Yet, sometimes you can’t beat the smooth, comfortable acceleration of a flat torque curve from the six cylinder. It really all comes down to what you prefer, though. We’re just here to provide the information to make a decision you’ll be happy with!

Weighing The Options: Mustang EcoBoost
ProsCons
- Wall of torque makes you say “Wow!” - Slightly more expensive, especially after adding the Performance Package
- Performance Package Option - Four Cylinder engine sound/exhaust note
- Better fuel economy - Need 93-octane fuel for maximum performance
- More Aftermarket Support  
- Premium Trim option  
Weighing The Options: Mustang V6
ProsCons
- Better exhaust note - No Performance Package Option
- Smooth torque curve = comfortable ride - Worse fuel economy
- Cheaper in price - No Premium Trim Option
- Only need 87-octane fuel for maximum performance - Less Aftermarket Support

Aftermarket Parts For Your V6 Or EcoBoost

There’s everything from blow off valves and wastegates, to cold air intakes, tuners and exhaust – all available for the EcoBoost Mustang. However, the options are limited when it comes to the V6. There are still options out there, just not as much variety. But don’t worry! We are adding parts to our inventory every day, including parts for the V6, so keep your eyes peeled on the CJ Pony Parts website, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and our YouTube channel for all the up-to-date info on your EcoBoost or V6 S550 Mustang parts!

Mustang V6 or EcoBoost?

If you’ve spent any time on our website surfing for 2015+ Mustang parts, you’ve probably already come to the conclusion that there definitely isn’t an equal amount of aftermarket parts for the V6 as there is for the EcoBoost. Ever since the 2.3L EcoBoost’s introduction as the non-V8 Mustang, there has been an overwhelming popularity for that platform over the 3.7L. This is due in part of Ford’s push for the EcoBoost platform and the serious potential for that motor upon turning the boost up.

Related Resources

Mustang Linear vs Progressive Springs Mustang Linear vs Progressive Springs

In this article, you’ll be able to learn the ins and outs of linear vs progressive springs on your Mustang. Then, you can make an educated decision on what’s best for your build. Are you a racer looking to get the absolute best handling when it comes to their Mustang? Linear is your answer. How about a daily driver and occasional weekend cruiser? Progressive is your go-to. Regardless of which you choose, CJ’s has an abundance of options to pick from, so get searching today!

Mustang Transmissions: Automatic vs Manual Mustang Transmissions: Automatic vs Manual

Whether it’s a weekend cruiser and easy daily driving that you’re after, or an all-around driver's car that is a blast to drive on the twisties, there really isn’t a right answer when it comes to choosing the right transmission for your Mustang. It comes down to personal preference and lifestyle.

2015-2017 Mustang Wheel & Tire Buying Guide 2015-2017 Mustang Wheel & Tire Buying Guide

Regardless of what style, finish and size wheel you’re looking for, CJ Pony Parts has the selection you need to outfit your S550 with the rims and tires that will set your car apart from the rest! Be sure to give us a call or order online and don’t hesitate to let us know if you have any questions. We are always happy to help!

Install Guide: 2015-2017 Mustang Roush Axle-Back Exhaust Install Guide: 2015-2017 Mustang Roush Axle-Back Exhaust

There's no doubt that the factory exhaust that comes on the 2015-2017 Mustang GT is quiet, restrictive and overall boring. That's where the Roush Axle-Back from Roush Performance steps in to provide better exhaust flow with a straight-through racing style muffler and an aggressive, throaty exhaust note. Find out how to install it in this guide!