1991 Mustang Shifters


Shifting gears is serious business. It doesn’t matter if your 1991 Mustang is manual or automatic, either. You want to be able to select the right gear quickly and with precision. A sloppy, lazy shifter can ruin your driving enjoyment and make you feel disconnected from your car. Our CJ Pony Parts shifter catalog includes some of the best-known names in performance shifters. Names like Hurst, Steeda and B&M. These shifter specialists have proven themselves over the years, so you know you’re getting a reliable, top-quality shifter that will give you the right feel and feedback. You’ll quickly get used to throwing your Mustang into gear and enjoying that satisfying feel of a tight, high-performance shifter.

Refine Your Search
Currently Selected
BizRate Circle of Excellence
BizRate Customer Certified (GOLD) Site - CJ Pony Parts Reviews at Bizrate
Norton Secured
Top 50 Fastest Growing Companies
Inc 5000 Honoree
Mustang Club of America Proud Sponsor
CJ Automotive Group
Pay with Affirm
Sort by
11 Results
Results per page
Sort by
11 Results
Results per page

1991 Shifters

Plenty of Choices

Not everyone wants the same shifter. Each Mustang enthusiast has their own preference for shifter feel and style. For that reason, our catalog is full of performance shifters for your 1991 Mustang, with options including:

• Steeda Tri-Ax Tremec 3550 manual transmission shifter
• B&M Hammer automatic transmission shifter
• Hurst Billet Plus Chrome manual transmission shifter

We carry these great shifters and many others. Not only do they offer a precise, accurate feel, but they are of high-quality construction and look great.

An attractive shifter really adds to the look of your interior and shows off the performance potential of your Mustang. When you’re overhauling your shifter, you can also choose from our collection of shift boots, trim pieces, and knobs and T-handles. Everyone can find the shifter and shifter parts they want with CJ Pony Parts! From full shifters to bolts, boots and bushings, it’s all just a few clicks away.

Time to Order

If you don’t already have an account at CJ Pony Parts, you can create one in just a few minutes. You can browse our online catalog and search for the 1991 Mustang parts you want. We have provided color photos and detailed descriptions of each part. With no minimum order requirement, you can order as few (or as many!) parts as you want, and still benefit from our fast shipping (free on most orders).

Get ready for a shifting revolution once you install your new Mustang shifter and get out on the road or track. You’ll find new excuses to shift gears, simply to feel that excellent connection between man and machine. Whether you’re replacing your worn, faulty shifter, upgrading your transmission or wanting the absolute in performance shifting, CJ Pony Parts has the shifter for you.

Not the year you are looking for? Check out these years: 1990, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, or 1998 for additional options.